Jesus wasn't 'just a good guy'

For believers and non-believers alike, there are many labels associated with Jesus Christ. The Messiah, The Anointed One, the Son of God. Sadly for many, we have the label "he was a good guy", or "just a good guy". This is a great shame and a disservice, whether you're a believer or not.

A crude comparison that can be made with Jesus (especially and obviously at Christmas time) is with Santa Claus. Many say with equal measure that "it would be nice to believe in God, but..." as "it would be nice to believe that Santa exists". This analogy also comes up when believers say that you can't disprove God, as the retort is "well, you can't disprove Santa, either". This brings me neatly on to a point that Paul Williams, the Vicar of Christ Church Fulwood in Sheffield, made at one of the Carol concerts recently. As the song goes, Santa "is making a list, he's checking it twice, gonna find out who's naughty and nice...he knows if you've been bad or good so be good for goodness sake". Paul made the point that Santa Claus is for good people, and you better not be on the 'naughty' list. This isn't the case with Jesus. Put simply, "it is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners" (Mark 2:17).

If we say that Jesus was 'just a good guy', then we water down hope. We reduce him to quotes and soundbites, used only to admonish people without looking at ourselves. People could quote "it's easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the Kingdom of God" to their heart's content, but if Jesus was 'just a good guy' then why quote him with authority? Why not simply quote similar sayings from celebrities and other historical figures? We could say 'Jesus was a good guy', but we could say the same of anyone. Think of the individuals that are revered around the world. We like to give them acclaim and highlight their success. Adele gets regular accolades as a musician; few people say "she's just a good singer". Even fewer people would say "Adele's a good singer, Joe down at the pub is a good singer; they're all good singers".

I don't intend this to be a put down of non-believers and a platform for believers, as I would be missing the point myself. The refusal to look at our own faults is a failure that can affect everyone and anyone. We are not justified by being on a 'good list', as we can't be justified that way. We are not saved by what we do ourselves. This is bread and butter theology to most Christians, but do we make others aware of this enough? There are still lingering stereotypes about trying to achieve a set standard, of being 'good enough'; this is not at all the point of the Christian faith, but if non-believers continue to have this preconception then I believe that as Christians we're not doing our job.

We (and especially I) can be too timid and accept the 'Jesus is a nice guy' line when we're with others. We can be too timid and accept a watering down of the gospel, so that we really do end up with the 'nice guy' reduction. If as Christians we don't really accept Jesus for who he was, and for who he said he was, then we are wasting our time. The line "he was delivered over to death for our sins and was raised to life for our justification" (Romans 4:25) must have meaning. John 3:16 must be a source of hope and not embarrassment and doubt: "For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life".

Are Christians ever hypocrites? Absolutely! There's no point in denying it. Jesus slammed the Pharisees when he said "you have a fine way of setting aside the commands of God in order to observe your own traditions!" (Mark 7: 9). Jesus was far more than 'just a good guy', and he had the authority and knowledge to say this. How often can we be guilty of doing much the same thing as is listed here in Mark? Again, we are not good witnesses if we do these things. We can't put ourselves on a pedestal above others. John 8:7: "Let any one of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone".

Jesus had an enormous impact on human history, whether you're a believer or not. He was not simply 'just a good guy'. As a Christian, it is the source of immense hope and faith to reject this label, but it is also a challenge. Discussion and great care is needed. People may well claim that belief in Jesus is akin to belief in Santa, but only one of those individuals accepts you for who you are; that's more than 'just good'.

Fairytale of New York is considered one of the classics. I loathe it with a passion.

I love Christmas every single year, but what I don’t love is the overplayed aforementioned song. I have to go through the same process annually; hear the depressing tones of The Pogues and Kirsty McColl in a shop somewhere, be that guy by mentioning my disdain for it in a group, and then finally get the “what?! I love it!” retort.

Why do I hate it? My reason is the most simple one: it’s so depressing. I concede my point to any Scrooges and Christmas sceptics who like this song, but I can never get past fellow Christmas lovers who cheerfully sing “You're a bum, you're a punk, you're an old slut on junk. Lying there almost dead on a drip in that bed”. Where’s the Christmas cheer in that? Furthermore, in the politically correct world that we live in, are we really comfortable to belt out the lyrics “You scumbag, you maggot, you cheap lousy faggot”? Whenever I hear that incredibly annoying opening drawl from the song, I desperately want to teleport somewhere else, Castiel-style from Supernatural. Not many songs make me want to do that, but having Fairytale of New York in my own personal bracket of Let it Go, Christmas Wrapping and Chasing Cars (to name a few random selections) isn't to be held in esteemed company.

For the record, I’m not intending to cast aspersions on the musical capabilities of The Pogues and Kirsty McColl. I’m also not a constant Christmas happy clapper who only likes cheery songs. I’ve no problem with Greg Lake’s I believe in Father Christmas, and I still like Do they know it’s Christmas? (the original 1984 version, of course). On the religious side, some of my favourite Christmas hymns are In the bleak midwinter, O Holy Night and O Come O Come Emmanuel, which are by no means cheerful and upbeat songs. There’s nothing wrong at all with having sombre and hard hitting reflections at Christmas time; quite the contrary.

I also don’t pretend to have an expert opinion on all things musical, and this is purely my own humble opinion on the song. As with some other songs (and indeed films), overplaying something can ultimately lead to it being overrated or irritating, and that could well apply to Fairytale of New York. I can understand people hating the Christmas songs that I like, as they too are prone to being overplayed. That’s enough of my concessions. If you don’t like Christmas and you like this song, I get it. However, I don’t understand people calling me a Scrooge for not liking Fairytale of New York; it’s a bit like accusing David Attenborough of being too uncaring towards wildlife whilst lighting a bonfire in the woods.

I don’t expect to make many friends from writing this article, and I’m unlikely to gain many converts to the anti-Fairytale of New York brigade. In a light hearted break from my usual political ramblings, maybe I’ve convinced one person to think “maybe he has a point”.